saas-marketing

Why Isn't My Marketing Working? 5 Real Reasons Founders Miss

Tried everything and nothing's working? Usually nothing got a real test, or the funnel leaks after it did. Here are the five reasons we see most often at Conversion Factory, how to tell which one is yours, and what to fix first.

Corey Haines··13 min read

"We've tried everything and nothing's working." Nick hears some version of that all the time on sales calls at Conversion Factory. I hear it from pre-revenue startups with zero dollars in MRR, and I hear it from Series B companies doing $10M in ARR. Same sentence, very different problems.

The short answer: when your marketing isn't working, it's usually one of two things. Either nothing got a real shot (the budget, timeframe, or effort was too small to ever produce a result), or something did get a real shot and the bucket leaks further down the funnel: positioning, the website, the brand, or the product itself. Figure out which one you're dealing with before you spend another dollar.

We spent a full episode of The Factory Floor on this. Here are the five reasons we see most often, how to tell which one is yours, and what to do about it.

What "we tried everything" usually means

"Tried everything, nothing is working" is a big claim. So the first question is always the same: what exactly did you try, for how long, and with what budget?

The answers are usually revealing. "We tried SEO" often means someone bought a couple of backlinks one time a year ago. "We tried ads" often means ten dollars a day for a few weeks. "We tried content" often means a bot scraped a bunch of articles and published them with no perspective in them at all.

None of those are real tests. They're samples too small to tell you anything. As Zach put it on the show, it's like eating healthy for one day a month and expecting it to change your diet.

The stage matters too. A startup throwing spaghetti at the wall to find its first customers has a different problem than a mature company that's plateauing, where every new thing it tries adds nothing incremental. Keep that in mind as you read the five reasons below. The first three are mostly early-stage problems. The last two show up at every stage.

Reason 1: Nothing got a real test

Most marketing tests are set up to fail before they start.

Take Meta ads. For the algorithm to even begin optimizing, finding the right people and getting you conversions at a reasonable cost, it needs roughly 50 conversion events a week per ad set. So if you put $10 a day into Meta with "book a demo" as the goal, you're not going to get anywhere near that. You get zero demos, call it a month, and conclude Meta doesn't work for your business. But did you really try Meta ads?

SEO is the same story on a longer clock. People publish a batch of pages, buy some backlinks, check their traffic a week later, and give up. Realistically, you need to wait about a year to see what SEO can do for you.

And A/B tests have their own version of this. If you don't let a test run until it reaches statistical significance (usually you want 95% confidence or higher), every test you run will "fail" by default. It's dead on arrival.

Here's what makes this hard. Marketing is a lot like baseball. If you get a hit three out of ten times, you're a Hall of Famer, which means you fail seven out of ten times. In marketing, almost everything looks like it's failing at first, right up until it isn't. There aren't many other parts of a business where you keep investing for months on the belief that the return will show up eventually.

What to do: before you start any channel, write down what a real test looks like. That means three things:

  1. The timeframe. For most channels, give it 100 days at least.
  2. The budget. Enough to give the platform the data it needs, like those 50 weekly conversion events on Meta.
  3. The bar for success. What result after 100 days would make you double down, and what would make you stop?

If you can't afford a real test of a channel right now, don't run a fake one. Save it for later.

Reason 2: Shiny object syndrome

Nick asked a good question on the episode: is shiny object syndrome just built into founders? People who start companies like doing new things. That's part of why they started a company. Then a post goes viral about someone who found a ton of customers through some strange new channel, and suddenly the SEO work gets dropped for the new thing.

I don't think you'll ever get rid of shiny object syndrome, and I don't think you should. Being early on new channels is a real advantage. Right now, the people dismissing AI and refusing to touch any of it are getting left behind in AEO. Exploring the new thing is often the right call.

The problem is switching too often. If you jump from tactic to tactic and never give any of them the time and budget they need, you'll never learn whether any of them work. You'll just have a long list of things you "tried."

What to do: channel the shiny object instead of fighting it. Keep one or two core channels running at full strength, and give the new thing its own small, defined test with a timeframe. Don't let it steal the budget and attention from the work that's already compounding.

Reason 3: You spread yourself too thin

A lot of founders try to test everything at once and end up testing nothing properly.

For ads, I wouldn't put $1,000 into Meta, $1,000 into Google, and $1,000 into LinkedIn to see which one works best. I'd put all $3,000 into Meta. If that struggles, take the $3,000 and move it to the next channel. Three underfunded tests give you three inconclusive answers. One funded test gives you a real one.

For SEO, don't start with the hardest keyword you could possibly pick and decide the whole channel is dead when you can't rank for it. Start with the easiest category instead. I'd literally start with keywords at a difficulty of 0 to 10. If you can't rank for those within a couple of months, you know SEO is going to be an uphill battle. If you can't rank for ten easy keywords, you're definitely not going to rank for twenty hard ones.

It's like poker. With a low pocket pair and three other people in the pot, you probably don't want to go all in. You want to be very sure before you spend $100,000 sponsoring a conference, pour $10K a month into ads, or hire a big marketing team. You want evidence first that your messaging and positioning are tight.

That also means making your long bets early. SEO in particular should start before your product is even live: get your pages indexed, build backlinks, build domain authority. Paid ads are the opposite. If you don't have product-market fit yet and you're still working out who you're for, ads will be very hard to make work, because ads need both of those things to perform.

What to do: pick one channel and fund it properly. Start with the easiest wins inside it. Make the slow bets (SEO, content, partnerships) as early as you can so you have time to see how they play out.

Reason 4: You repeat the same play

The opposite failure is also real. Sticking with a channel doesn't mean banging your head against the same wall a hundred times. Doing the exact same thing over and over and expecting different results is the definition of insanity.

Take organic social. If I posted the exact same format every day for 100 days, I don't think I'd learn much. I'd have run one experiment a hundred times.

What I'd do instead is work in batches:

  1. Post ten pieces in a few different formats.
  2. Look at the data. Did one outperform the other nine? What about it might have worked?
  3. Make the next ten emphasize that thing. If batch three flops, go back to batch two and form a different hypothesis.

Keep going until you find what wins. Every round should have a hypothesis, a test, and an update.

Failed tests count here too. Nick made a good point on the show: if you test ten messaging angles and seven don't land, those seven are just as useful as the three that do, as long as you write down what you learned and use it. A failed test didn't produce ROI, but it did produce information.

The other part of this is taking bigger swings. A lot of A/B tests are too small to matter. If all you changed was the button text, don't be surprised when nothing moves. Big changes to copy, layout, and structure produce big differences in results, in either direction, and that's how you learn something.

What to do: iterate, don't pivot. Small, deliberate changes between batches. Bigger swings inside each test.

Reason 5: Your bucket leaks

Now let's assume the opposite of everything above. You gave each channel the time, budget, and statistical significance it needed, and it still didn't work. This is where a lot of companies come to us, convinced something is broken.

Most of the time, what we find is leaky bucket syndrome. Time, money, and traffic are pouring into the top of the funnel, but by the time people get to the bottom, where they'd sign up and pay you, most of them have leaked out.

The buyer awareness stages are a helpful way to see where:

  • Unaware: they don't know they have the problem.
  • Problem aware: they know the problem but not the solutions.
  • Solution aware: they know the kinds of solutions but not yours.
  • Product aware: they know your product but haven't chosen it.
  • Fully aware: they're ready to buy, or already a customer.

If people stall at problem aware or solution aware, more traffic won't fix it. And usually the reason they stall is a weak foundation: an unoptimized website, no conversion best practices, positioning that's off, a brand that's off, or a site where people can't tell what you do.

Nick's line from the sales seat sums it up: "You don't have a traffic problem, you have a conversion problem." It doesn't matter how much you spend on ads if the rest of the funnel isn't working.

The tricky part is that you usually can't see this in your own marketing. Zach calls it pickle jar syndrome: you're inside the jar, so you can't read the label you put on the outside years ago. Someone looking from the outside can see it right away.

Where most leaks start

When we look at why a bucket leaks, it usually traces back to one of two foundational mistakes.

You're too broad. You're trying to be too many things for too many people. If you're a CRM for anybody and everybody, good luck. There are a hundred generic CRMs off the shelf. What's your angle? Is there a specific person, feature set, or use case you can really nail? You can test several. With clients, we'll try creators, then podcasters, then fintech, then a specific vertical, and see what clicks. Founders are usually scared of this because they don't want to shrink their TAM. But being specific is a competitive advantage, and it's a big reason vertical SaaS has it easier on positioning.

You're describing it in a way that doesn't click. Someone pitched me an "AEO tool" recently. The more he explained it, the more confused I got, so I finally asked him to break it down like I'm an idiot. What does the software actually do? It turned out it takes transcripts of video calls and turns them into AI-generated videos you can use in ads. That's a fine product. It just isn't an AEO tool, and nobody buying would ever figure that out from the pitch.

There's a lot of pressure with AI to describe yourself in big category words. You're not a meeting recorder or a note taker, you're a "team intelligence platform." Please don't. Just say what your product is and who it's for.

Brand plays into this too. If you line your site up next to your three closest competitors and you're all using the same color palette, the same dark background, and the same look, buyers have no easy way to tell you apart. Most founders never take the time to step back and examine their competitive landscape, and it's understandable, because they have a hundred other things on their plate. But until you do, your foundation stays cracked. (We wrote more about this in symptoms of bad branding.)

What to do: walk your funnel backwards from revenue. Close rate, then demo or trial quality, then site conversion, then traffic. Find the first step that's broken and fix that before you add more traffic. And know what each channel actually delivers to the bottom of the funnel: who it brings to the sales call, not just how many.

When the answer is in the product

The least common version of "we've tried everything" comes from mature companies, and the answer there often has nothing to do with marketing.

Sometimes the company is losing product-market fit, or churn is higher than anyone wants to admit. Or it has hit its revenue ceiling. Jason Cohen's Max MRR concept is worth studying here: it's the point where the new MRR coming in from new customers equals the MRR you're losing to churn. Everything cancels out, and it looks like marketing stopped working.

It didn't. Your marketing is still working. It's just being canceled out by churn. At that point you need a lot more marketing, or you need to fix churn. It's the same leaky bucket, just a very controlled leak. You can make the hole smaller, but it'll never go away entirely, so you have to manage it.

What to do this week

If you're stuck in "we've tried everything," here's where I'd start:

  1. List everything you've "tried." Next to each one, write down how long it ran, what you spent, and what result you expected. Cross off anything that didn't get a real test.
  2. Pick one channel and set a 100-day bar. Fund it properly, start with the easiest wins inside it, and decide up front what success looks like.
  3. Walk your funnel backwards. Find the first leak between traffic and revenue. If people can't tell who you're for from your homepage, fix that first. Our guide to SaaS website design is a good place to start.

If you're not sure what stage you're in, our breakdown of the three phases of SaaS marketing will help you match channels to where you actually are.

As Zach said at the end of the episode: "No silver bullets, only a thousand gold BBs."

Frequently asked questions

Why is my marketing not working?

Usually one of two reasons. Either nothing got a real test (too little budget, too short a timeframe, or too little effort), or a channel did get a real test and the funnel leaks afterward because of positioning, the website, the brand, or the product. Start by checking which one applies before you change channels.

How long should you test a marketing channel before quitting?

For most channels, give it at least 100 days. Some take longer: SEO usually needs about a year to show what it can do. Decide on your timeframe, budget, and success bar before you start so you're judging the test, not your mood that week.

How much should I spend to test Meta ads?

Enough for the algorithm to learn. Meta needs roughly 50 conversion events per week per ad set before it can optimize well. If your budget can't get close to that for your conversion goal, choose a higher-volume event to optimize for, or wait until you can fund a real test.

How do I know if my website is the problem?

Walk your funnel backwards from revenue. If plenty of people are reaching your site but few sign up, book a demo, or buy, you have a conversion problem, and more traffic won't fix it. A quick check: can a stranger tell what you do and who it's for from your homepage in a few seconds?

What is leaky bucket syndrome in marketing?

It's when you keep pouring time, money, and traffic into the top of your funnel, but most people leak out before they become customers. The usual causes are an unoptimized website, weak positioning, a brand that blends in with competitors, or product churn.

Should I stop chasing new marketing channels?

No. Being early on new channels like AEO is a real advantage. Just don't let the new thing replace your core channels before they've had a fair test. Give each new channel its own defined test with a budget and a timeframe.

Share

Watch the episode

Why Isn't My Marketing Working? 5 Real Reasons Founders Miss

Not sure if Conversion Factory is the right fit?

Let’s chat. We’ll answer all your questions and give you an honest assessment on if we can add substantial value to you.

On-demand marketing, design, and web dev
No contracts
First month happiness guarantee
SavvyCal
Marketing · Design

SavvyCal

23× MRR growth

Senja
Marketing · Design · Framer

Senja

17% conversion lift

Join It
Marketing · Design · Webflow

Join It

43% More conversions

100+ startups trust Conversion Factory

DragonGlassTokensoftDevStatsCurePathMaple BlueBaremetricsEvercastKinectAirSupereventAudienceTapSavvyCalTimetasticCordialSensible
DragonGlassTokensoftDevStatsCurePathMaple BlueBaremetricsEvercastKinectAirSupereventAudienceTapSavvyCalTimetasticCordialSensible