conversion-rate-optimization

AI Marketing Is a Dumpster Fire—Here’s How to Fix It

AI marketing is a mess—vague messaging, generic visuals, and AI hype without substance. Here’s why it’s failing and how to fix it.

Corey Haines

2

Open LinkedIn, Twitter, or any recent SaaS pitch deck and you'll see the same pattern. AI CRM. AI website builder. AI workflow platform. AI accounting tool. Two years into the AI wave, almost every product is being marketed the same way — and almost none of it is working.

We're not anti-AI. We use it every day. But the way most AI products are being marketed is doing real damage — to the category, to buyer trust, and probably to your conversion rate if you're running the standard playbook.

Here's why it's failing, and what to do instead.

Why most AI marketing falls flat

"AI" has been said into meaninglessness

The word has been repeated so often that it no longer registers. It's the modern equivalent of marketing software by mentioning what database it uses — technically true, useless to the buyer.

The deeper problem is that "AI" describes a technology, not a benefit. When every competitor leads with the same prefix, the word stops doing any work for you. Your buyer's ears perk up the first time they see "AI [category]." They glaze over by the tenth.

Most AI companies start with the tech, not the problem

Look at Y Combinator's recent requests-for-startups list. Almost every idea is framed as "AI for X." That mirrors what most AI founders are doing: picking the technology first, then hunting for a problem to attach it to.

That order is backwards. Strong products start with a real customer problem and pick the technology that solves it. AI-first product thinking produces a generation of features in search of users — and marketing copy that has to dance around the fact that the product doesn't have a clear purpose yet.

We've seen this exact pattern before

If you were paying attention to tech in 2021, this all feels familiar. Blockchain. Web3. NFTs. Same dynamic: a real underlying technology with legitimate applications, hijacked by a wave of companies that emphasized the mechanism over the benefit, raised funding on hype, and produced a public skeptical of the entire category.

NFTs had genuine use cases — proof of ownership, certification, transfer of digital assets. But the public saw $80,000 cartoon apes and decided the whole thing was a scam. AI is at risk of the same fate. The legitimate applications are being drowned out by companies that haven't figured out what their product actually does.

Why putting "AI" in your product name is a mistake

The most common AI marketing pattern goes like this: we're the AI [category] for [audience].

It feels punchy. It signals you're on-trend. It's also doing almost no work for you.

It doesn't differentiate

If every CRM, every website builder, and every accounting tool now has "AI" attached, the prefix isn't a differentiator. It's a category marker. You've described what you've built but said nothing about why someone should pick you over the other 50 companies running the same play.

It will age you fast

In two years — maybe sooner — "AI" in your brand name will read like ".com" in a 2001 startup name. AI is being absorbed into every product on the market. By the time the dust settles, you won't need to announce AI any more than you need to announce that your software runs in the cloud.

If you've baked "AI" into your company name, your URL, or your H1, you're tethering your brand to a feature window that's about to close.

"AI as a feature" vs. "AI in features"

Most companies make a related mistake: turning AI into a feature — the Clippy-style assistant, the chat bubble in the corner, the "Try Notion AI" button — rather than embedding it invisibly into the features users already use.

Nobody asked for Salesforce AI. Nobody asked for Stripe AI. Buyers want their existing CRM and payment workflows to be faster, smarter, and easier — without having to learn a new chat interface to get there. The strongest AI implementations don't announce themselves. They make the product noticeably better at the things it's always done.

How to market an AI product people actually want to buy

A handful of patterns that work — and that more AI companies should steal.

Pick a real ICP and obsess over their problem

Visual Electric is the canonical good example. It's an AI image generator, just like Midjourney and DALL-E and a hundred others. But its target is specific: designers. People who care about depth of field, brand consistency, art direction, and Figma integration.

That focus shows up everywhere on their site. The headline is "a camera for your mind," not "the AI image platform for creative teams." The features are designer-specific: art director, style libraries, brand consistency. The integrations are designer tools: Figma, Framer, Webflow.

The result: in a category absolutely flooded with AI image generators, Visual Electric doesn't look like any of them. They look like the tool for designers. That's what real differentiation looks like.

Make AI invisible — embed it in features

Zapier quietly shipped a feature recently where you describe what you want in plain text and it builds the automation for you. No Clippy, no chatbot, no "Try Zapier AI" banner — just a small text input that says "describe what you want to do."

It works perfectly. It saves a hundred clicks. And it's a far better demonstration of AI's value than any "we're now an AI company" announcement.

If you're building AI into a product, this is the model: deliver the outcome, not the technology. Let the user feel what AI made possible without making them adapt to a new interface.

Tell the before/after story

The most underused AI marketing move is the simplest: paint the picture of how a task used to work and how it works now.

Remember when you used to look through stock photo libraries for hours and pay a dollar every time someone viewed an image? Now you make your own — perfectly tailored, royalty-free, in seconds.

That's a real value prop. Specific. Concrete. It implicitly explains why AI matters without saying the word "AI." And it's the kind of clarity almost no AI homepage offers.

If your product replaces a workflow people have been doing the same way for ten years, lead with that contrast. The before/after does more selling than any feature list.

Show real proof, not AI-generated reviews

The hype phase has trained buyers to be skeptical. Generic case studies, AI-written testimonials, and vague "10x faster" claims now read as red flags rather than proof.

What works is the opposite: real customer stories with specific numbers (hours saved, costs reduced, deals closed), named contacts, and detail that couldn't have been generated. The lift from authentic proof has gotten higher precisely because so much of the content out there is fake.

Drop "AI" from your name and your tagline

Unless you're building foundational models, your company isn't an AI company. You're a CRM company that uses AI. A website builder that uses AI. A copywriting tool that uses AI.

Calling yourself an "AI company" inflates expectations you can't meet, invites comparison to OpenAI and Anthropic, and tethers your brand to a label that will age out of relevance. Be honest about what you build. The product gets stronger when the marketing matches the truth.

Look like yourself, not like every other AI company

Most AI startups have converged on the same visual language: amorphous gradient logos, abstract orb shapes, futuristic blues and purples. If you cropped the wordmarks off ten AI company sites, you couldn't tell them apart.

Visual differentiation is downstream of ICP. An AI product built for the construction industry should look nothing like one built for designers, which should look nothing like one built for healthcare. If your visual brand looks like everyone else's, that's usually a sign you haven't picked a customer yet.

The window for AI marketing is closing

The strongest argument for fixing this now is timing.

For the next couple of years, you can still tell a customer "this thing you've been doing the same way for a decade now works completely differently." That contrast is powerful. People remember the before/after. They share it.

In three years, that window closes. AI will be embedded in every product they use. The "you used to do it this way, now you can do it that way" frame won't land, because the new way will be the default. Differentiating then will require working much harder — on brand, on ICP, on product opinions — without the easy lift of contrast.

If you're an AI-augmented company, the time to do this work is right now: pick your customer, kill the jargon, show the before/after, and let the AI itself do its work in the background.

Frequently asked questions

Why is most AI marketing so generic?

Because most companies are leading with the technology instead of the customer problem. "AI CRM" or "AI website builder" describes what's under the hood, not what the buyer gets out of it. When every competitor leads with the same prefix, none of them differentiate. Better AI marketing starts with a specific user, a specific problem, and a clear before/after — and treats AI as the engine rather than the headline.

Should I put "AI" in my product name or tagline?

Probably not, unless your product is a foundational AI model. AI is being absorbed into every category, which means "AI" in your name will start reading as dated within a year or two. It also doesn't differentiate when every competitor is doing it. Lead with the outcome you deliver. Let AI sit in the background.

How do I differentiate when everyone is using the same AI models?

The differentiation lives in your ICP, your interface, and your application — not in the underlying model. Visual Electric uses the same kinds of models as everyone else, but their narrow focus on designers makes them feel like a different product. Pick a specific customer. Solve their specific problem. Treat the model as a commodity input.

What's the difference between "AI features" and "AI in features"?

"AI features" (like a chat bubble in the corner of your app) make AI a separate thing the user has to learn and engage with. "AI in features" (like Zapier's natural-language automation builder) makes the existing features quietly better. Most users prefer the second model — they don't want to interact with AI, they want their tools to do more for them.

Are AI startups going to crash like blockchain startups did?

Some will. Companies that built on hype without solving a real problem are vulnerable, just as they were in the blockchain wave. The companies that survive will be the ones using AI to solve specific, valuable problems for specific customers — not the ones whose pitch is "we're an AI company." The technology is real and durable. The marketing froth around it is not.

Is it worth registering a .ai domain for my AI product?

Probably not as a primary domain. The .com is still the default that buyers type and remember, and .ai will read as dated once AI is ubiquitous in software. The exception is if your brand name itself ends in "AI" and the .ai domain genuinely fits — but even then, the long-term play is owning the .com.

Share

Watch the episode

AI Marketing Is a Dumpster Fire—Here’s How to Fix It

Not sure if Conversion Factory is the right fit?

Let’s chat. We’ll answer all your questions and give you an honest assessment on if we can add substantial value to you.

On-demand marketing, design, and web dev
No contracts
First month happiness guarantee
SavvyCal
Positioning & copy

SavvyCal

23x MRR growth

Less Annoying CRM
Homepage redesign

Less Annoying CRM

20% more conversions

Botable
Rebrand & website

Botable

85% shorter sales cycle

Senja
Landing page & CRO

Senja

17% conversion lift

Sensible
Design & Webflow

Sensible

2x committed ARR

100+ startups trust Conversion Factory

DragonGlassTokensoftDevStatsCurePathMaple BlueBaremetricsEvercastKinectAirSupereventAudienceTapSavvyCalTimetasticCordialSensible
DragonGlassTokensoftDevStatsCurePathMaple BlueBaremetricsEvercastKinectAirSupereventAudienceTapSavvyCalTimetasticCordialSensible
Book a call